Mariah Carey sparks yearly Christmas event in this forum, I'd say she's better than Taylor Swift lol
Honestly it's not a close comparison. Taylor wipes the floor with Mariah in every respect except pure vocal range. I'll take a 2nd rate Taylor song over Mariah's best every time.
Gaga used to be the bizz. PINK and christina aguilera (dirty comes to mind) are better to me than swift. But if it's just a popularity contest, then I can see how people prefer the blank slate.
Gaga has vocal chops, and she makes a better run at Taylor than Mariah, but Gaga isn't half the songwriter Taylor is. Pink's songs always lack a second gear. Pink's tracks always lay out great promise and just every time they come up slightly short of what they set out to do. Always leaves me with the impression that she under achieves.
Aguilera is a voice and that's about it. You have to be aware when comparing Aguilera to Taylor that she's not even doing the things that make Taylor great. Taylor has a great voice, it's not Aguilera's voice, but it is great. But Taylor actually writes... a lot... and across genres that musicians have rarely crossed.
Taylor isn't just a great vocalist (which is where the Mariah/Aguilera discussions come in), but she's a writer who actually writes chart-topping songs, and an innovator on top of that. Honestly Aguilera is a bit of an insult.
Number 1 songs:
Fortnight | 5/04/2024 | 1 |
Is It Over Now? (Taylor's Version) | 11/22/2023 | 1 |
Cruel Summer | 10/28/2023 | 4 |
Anti-Hero | 11/05/2022 | 8 |
All Too Well (Taylor's Version) | 11/27/2021 | 1 |
Willow | 12/26/2020 | 1 |
Cardigan | 08/08/2020 | 1 |
Look What You Made Me Do | 09/16/2017 | 3 |
Bad Blood | 06/06/2015 | 1 |
Blank Space | 11/29/2014 | 7 |
Shake It Off | 09/06/2014 | 4 |
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together | 09/01/2012 | 3 |
Since her first number 1 in 2012, amazingly the only years without a swift number 1 song are 2013, 2016, and 2018-19. 12 in 12 years.